Russian Orthodox Church Suspends Relations With Swedish Lutherans Over Gay Marriages

MosNews

The Moscow Patriarchate has suspended relations with the Evangelical-Lutheran Church of Sweden after it decided to establish an official ceremony to bless homosexual couples, the Interfax news agency reported on Tuesday.

“We have received with great disappointment and grief the news that not only does the Lutheran Church of Sweden not oppose so-called homosexual marriages, but has even ruled to establish an official blessing ceremony,” the Holy Synod of the Russian Orthodox Church said in a statement at a session in Moscow.
more

15 thoughts on “Russian Orthodox Church Suspends Relations With Swedish Lutherans Over Gay Marriages”

  1. The Orthodox Church is not “against gay marriage” at all. Such a thing as “gay marriage” does not exist in free mankind, mankind in its natural state. The Orthodox Church is for sanctification. It is our boat to Salvation, back to Heaven where we really belong but chose to abandon. One of the paths to salvation for many people is through Holy Matrimony that gives opportunities everyday for self-sacrificial love.
    So the Orthodox Church is very much for marriage. Nothing more to say. Not for â??heterosexual marriageâ?? as that only states the obvious. The definition of marriage is not a concept that can change according to what society deems right in one era or the other. The word “marriage” always means the Sacrament that unites a woman and a man into a mystical unity of spirit and body blessed by God.
    The Love that can develop from such a close bond is unlimited. It can overflow so that children can be born from it and rejoice in it, family, friends and the rest of society benefit greatly by a good marriage. The husband and wife are called by our wonderful loving Church to serve each other in love, putting each other first denying their own will and desires to serve each other! What a high calling! Iâ??d say what a heroic act, a terrible promise! We can all imagine how hard this is but also what strong bonds it creates.

    Now for our poor brothers and sisters that have fallen so deeply in habitual sin that they are bonded by it, they try to persuade those who are not yet as wounded that their wounds are sweet, we have to stand our ground so at least we can be there to help them come to their senses if they so try.
    Lets know those basic things.
    It is immense foolishness for 2 men or 2 women to try and become a unity. This cannot be for the simple reason that God created mankind in His image. But please pay attention, he did not just create Adam in His image. Mankind consists immediately of 2 sexes the male and female which together are in the image of God!!! This truth is lost in our everyday limited language, but it is so clear and our holy Fathers teach us so.
    Please do take a look at our Bibleâ??s very first chapter and see what it clearly states in: Genesis 1
    26 Then God said, “Let us make man in our image, in our likeness, and let THEM rule over the fish of the sea and the birds of the air, over the livestock, over all the earth, and over all the creatures that move along the ground.”
    27 So God created man in his own image,
    in the image of God he created him;
    MALE AND FEMALE he created them.
    Pretty clear. Mankind has two sexes that in a mystical unity are created in Godâ??s image. That is why couples refer to each other as â??my other halfâ??. Because their natural state is their unity. They are inseparable not because of superficial emotions but because of a blessed mystical unity. This has been established right from our very existence and happens throughout the ages even to non-Christians because that is mankindâ??s natural state. (Of course monks and nuns live the life of the Angels on earth and are wedded to Chris Himself. This is not contradictory to our topic).

    I say “gay marriage” does not exist and I do not mean that it simply does not exist because state law or Church canons don’t allow it, but because it is a concept that very perverted minds have come up with, THEY put the idea together. It is not an idea that preexists in nature and waits for us to discover it like scientific knowledge.
    All it is is the perversion of our natural state. Just like all abuse. To eat is healthy and mandatory, to overeat brings disease and death. To marry is the blessed state of mankind, to pervert those relationships is to destruct the concept of our very existence, to destruct LOVE itself.
    They have decided to shove their perversion down our throats in recent times.To make it “socially acceptable” just like with many other things. They are very successful despite the utter nonsense they support, because WE ARE LAZY and do not even know what we stand for. In free (free thinking, holy blessed) humankind many things do not exist, such as “innocent extra-marital affairs”, “choice to kill” a baby, “choice to euthanize” those annoying older parents but perverse minds talk about it over and over and we who do not lead a devout spiritual life but are only Christians by name, grow so accustomed to such lies that we have no reaction! We have a responsibility to at least let those people know that the path they have chosen is certainly not as rosy as they may be deceived by their blindness to think.

    Knowledge of Truth does not really come to us by deep theological study. Studying our Faith certainly is helpful, but living the Sacramental life is what brings us the knowledge of Truth. That is because Thruth is not a system of ideas like the Enlightment proponents would have us believe. Christ Himself is THE TRUTH. He brings us understanding of very important and difficult things by getting closer to Him through the sacraments of our Holy Church. He said:
    “I am the way and the truth and the life.” (John 14:6)

    Pretty simple really for us to gain eternal life. We are given the map, the tools and even guides and fellow Christians. Even a designated Angel! Here’s everything:
    Go to confession, prepare and receive communion, have a prayer rule, read the Holy Scriptures and Orthodox books and have humility so we’ll guard ourselves from heresies and other temptations.
    Lets fight in the battle. It is very real, it is right hear right now against the spiritual powers of this world and against our own fallen nature. We are on the winning side though! Christ is Risen! All we need to do is be awake in the battle field!
    The spiritual battle field, not the “social wars”. Those are transient, always will exist as they always have and bring no salvation.

    Forgive my tone if it has come off strong. These things though should have us outraged, not confused!

    I will be glad to hear other comments!
    Lets cheer each other along in the battle sister!
    In Christ,
    Dia

  2. My initial greeting unfortunately got deleted last night during my copying and pasting.
    so:
    Dear Olympiada,

    Christ is born! Glorify Him!
    Thank you for raising such a topic. I could not pass it up despite being dead tired!

    So, of course for conception to take place it only takes a sperm and an egg. Who said otherwise?
    But what blessing it is when the conception is a product of love!
    Note that when love overflows children can be born because of it and rejoice in it. I didn’t say that this is the only condition where a child can be born 😉

    If this belief (of love producing children) is strong amongst traditional Orthodox couples it is because it is unthinkable to have sexual relations with someone you do not love!
    Also there are couples that love each other but cannot have children. No contradiction.

    Some Orthodox may be very humble in Church sometimes, they may have come from other lands so their accent or vocabulary are not perfect, but there are many highly educated members amongst us.
    If they have views contrary to american main streem it may be that indeed they know better. Such immense differences in attitude and worldviews can seem mistaken or naive to those who do not have the same mindset, or historical and philosophical perspective but there may be some wisdom to learn from rather than quickly criticize.
    In any case, noone understands Orthodoxy by critically examining it. It is not a set of philosophical ideas to contemplate. It is an experiential revelation. You understand it by doing it.

    I also realized that I did not directly address your main point:
    “what relevance gay marriage has to me as a straight Orthodox woman? ”

    I think it is good to see that Truth is defended within the Church (and the Orthodox Church is the Church, all others are “churches”)
    We should be very upset if someone in the Orthodox Church thought to push such an anticanonical but also unatural idea such as trying to create a unity from people of the same sex. We also should glorify God that evidently our Church firmly defends the Truth and does not become game to whatever modern ideas of each era dictate.
    So as Orthodox women we can be thankful for knowing the Truth and praying for our clergy to “rightfully preach the word” of God’s Truth.

  3. Christ is Born! Glorify Him!

    We cannot really call ouselves Orthodox until we have submitted our hearts, minds, and souls to the love of Jesus Christ in the Church. Faith in the Church is one of the requirements. That faith is not and should not be a blind faith. We cannot however develop the mind and soul of the critic especially if we use the standards of the world to be critical of the Church. The critic is sarcastic, cynical and filled with doubt.

    As regards ordination. There is far too much emphsis on achievement of rank through ordination. The emphasis should be on serving Christ in the situation of our daily lives, whatever those may be. If our eye be single on Christ in all that we do, we will be living a sacramental life that transforms and transfigures many around us by the Grace of God. That is the full Eucharist, and that is where our priesthood lies.

    How often do we enter our inner sancuary and offer the sacrifice of praise, repentence, and obediance? How often do we pay attention to the hurts and stuggles of those closest to us, inviting them into our bubble of Light not by words, but by deeds?

    Several people have commented that the arguments for a male only priesthood are archaic and illogical. Well, I find that the arguments for females in the priesthood are narcisistic, power oriented ideology. I think it would be a mistake to attempt to develop a specific teaching on male priesthood against women. That is not what the Church is about and to do so only gives victory to those who wish to radically and unnecessarily change the whole fabric and substance of the Church. Instead we must forcefully teach and live the full tradition of the Church that demonstrates the nature of sacrament, Theosis, and salvation.

    Christ is Born! Glorify Him!

  4. Michael writes: “We cannot really call ouselves Orthodox until we have submitted our hearts, minds, and souls to the love of Jesus Christ in the Church. Faith in the Church is one of the requirements. That faith is not and should not be a blind faith. We cannot however develop the mind and soul of the critic especially if we use the standards of the world to be critical of the Church. The critic is sarcastic, cynical and filled with doubt.”

    Thomas Merton made a distinction between intellectual difficulties and theological doubt. In my observation, many people equate intellectual difficulty with theological doubt. But I think there is an important difference.

    In my view — perhaps yours too — theology is something that is experienced, not derived from rational propositions. But even rationality can lead one to theology. As Protestant theologian Albert Schweitzer noted in his _Philosophy of Civilization_, rational thought taken to its end leads to mysticism. Many people see rationality as the same as secularism, but it doesn’t have to be.

    It seems to me that the job of the church is to meet people where they are, not where they would have been 2,000 years ago. The church needs to show people that the truths of faith are not excluded by rationality — that rationality and theology need not be incompatible. In other words, the church needs to show people that having a rational worldview does not exclude the truths of theology. Which is to say that mystery and rationality can exist together.

  5. Jim said,

    “It seems to me that the job of the church is to meet people where they are, not where they would have been 2,000 years ago.”

    Jim, What does this mean? Could you give an example or two please? Thanks.

  6. Rationality founded on materialism is false. Rationality founded on the existence of a loving God who incarnated and gave himself up for the life of the world is what the Church has always taught. In the heart of the the Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom the priest offers thanks for the rational and bloodless sacrifice.

    Demons are real, they do inhabit and influence people all the time. Angels also exist too. I know this, I have experienced it.

    The miraculous happens all the time. Just read the documented lives of recent saints such as St. John Maxomovitch, Wonderworker of Shanghai and San Francisco who reposed in 1966. A little further back, St. John of Kronstadt who reposed in 1907.

    I’ll give you an even more immediate example that I found out about just today: four years ago a close friend of mine lost one of her twin girls in the womb. She has been, by her own account, inconsolable ever since–her grief driving her into dispair. This summer, she went to Romania and had a brief private meeting with a monk there who suffered under the Communists. He lifted the debilitating part of her grief from her. He just did it. She says, he saved her life, in fact her life and the life of her family is completely changed for the better.

    Such everyday miracles of life in the Church are not talked about much because they are quite common, but rationally inacessable until one has first accepted Jesus Christ as one of the Holy Trinity who incarnated for us and for our salvation, went to the cross, resurrected and ascended plus all of the other foundational beliefs of Christianity embodied in the orginal Nicean Creed which includes the Virginity of Mary.

    So many people cry out for proof, the proof has been given thousands of times over, but if you don’t have eyes to see, you will not see.

  7. Jerry writes: “Jim concerning your views about miracles, what then is your belief about the Eucharist?”

    I don’t really have a belief, per se. Like most things in Christianity, I see the Eucharist as something to be experienced rather than explained. Personally, I have no problem with the miraculous, especially if we’re talking about the kind of “everyday miracle” described earlier by Michael. I don’t even rule out the possibility of actual physical miracles.

    My main point is that people in the West increasingly do not conceive of life and the world in terms of the miraculous. To insist that people today must believe in specific miracles is like showing up in Japan with Mexican pesos instead of yen. There’s nothing wrong with pesos, but they are just incomprehensible pieces of paper to most people in Japan. In my view, making Christianity “relevant” to people of today is little more than going to Japan with yen instead of pesos.

  8. Note 18: I’m not sure early peoples accepted the miraculous as commonplace. It seems that the miracles attributed to Christ were often treated with skepticism if not outright scorn, even though the things he did were a bit more “showy” than the everyday banalities I often hear Christians today label as “miracles”. The attitude seems to be, even after walking on water or raising someone from the dead, something like “That was pretty cool … but can you do anything else?” or “Eh … maybe there’s some other explanation for it”. I’d actually be more suspicious of the Gospels if there were no doubters, but there seemed to be plenty.

    As far as making Christianity “relevant”, I don’t think Christianity really offered what people were looking for, even in the time of Christ. They wanted some sort of warrior or king, and what they got certainly seemed to defy their desires, needs and expectations. I’m not sure that we’re not going to feel the same sense of disappointment, if you will, today. I hesitate to use that word, but Christianity (at least for me) does not offer the nice explanations, guarantees and assurances that I personally would like to have.

  9. JamesK writes: “I’m not sure early peoples accepted the miraculous as commonplace. It seems that the miracles attributed to Christ were often treated with skepticism if not outright scorn . . .”

    Unbelievers may have have doubted the miracles attributed to Jesus, but they didn’t doubt the idea of miracles — as one can see with the early Christian critic Celsus.

    JamesK: “As far as making Christianity “relevant”, I don’t think Christianity really offered what people were looking for, even in the time of Christ.”

    Well . . . then you have to explain how Christians became so numerous is a relatively short amount of time, and in an era without printing press or mass media. Studies have been done on the many factors related to the spread of Christianity, but surely one of them was that Christianity was relevant to the potential converts.

    JamesK: “They wanted some sort of warrior or king, and what they got certainly seemed to defy their desires, needs and expectations.”

    Certainly Jesus would not have fulfilled the expectations of the Jewish leadership in Israel. But Christianity did spread among the hellenized Jews and among the gentiles who went to Jewish synagoges throughout the region, in addition to those who had no Jewish affiliation.

  10. Olympiada,
    Thanks for clarifying. We really are not in disagreement at all. We both agree that our own will can lead to selfish actions. All I added to the point is that God intends us to live our life unselfishly but allows us to do as we please.
    Jim,
    I think I got your point. Which I think is:
    In early Christian times all people were accustomed to the idea of miraculous interventions and everyone believed in all sorts of spirits occupying the earth and interfering with human life. Nowadays people just do not really believe in the supernatural.
    As Orthodox though we do fully believe in the existence of the Holy Trinity as the one God and creator of everything else material and immaterial. Part of that creation are also the Angels and the fallen angels, the demons. Our own souls are also never dead, they never cease to exist but only enter eternity after the short life on this earth. We also believe in miracles big and smaller and have a pretty significant mystical component intertwined in our Faith and everyday life practices.
    So all this would probably be too much for a Western raised person to accept. Too much “supernatural nonsense” that cannot be proven or even worse perhaps, observed, studied and experimented with in controlled environments.
    But this is where the comment on those â??who have earsâ?? goes.
    You cannot approach Faith with the rational tools used for the study of the seen (and created) world. Of course we can theologize, explain many things, do comparative studies, determine if something agrees with our dogmatic thesis or not, study the history of Christianity and all these good things with our intellect.
    However we understand Faith with faith. We have the desire to understand, so we humbly practice what weâ??ve been taught, and learn more in the process. Living by the principles our Tradition and Church canons teach we grow. We sometimes do things without understanding the reason or their significance, but slowly as we go along we learn something new and understand larger pieces of the puzzle.
    We believe in attracting the Holy Spirit by living a godly life. The more we clean out our hearts to make room for Christ, the more He abides in us. It is through the Holy Spirit that we gain understanding, not through our intellectual endeavors. That is why we pray and must pray more and more. Pray and ask for spiritual gifts too. Ask for reverence, humility, patience, obedience, trust. We attract the Holy Spirit with a holy lifestyle though, not just by agreeing with a system of beliefs. Orthodoxy is not some philosophical set of ideas to agree with, but a certain direction to adopt in life. â??I believeâ?? means I think it is so, and I do according to this. It does not mean that I simply accept some principles as true, but that I also change my life and see that my actions befit the principles I hold true. So we attract the Holy Spirit by abiding in Christ, leading an Orthodox lifestyle (with the Sacraments as the center) and the more â??illuminedâ?? we become the more we understand as we read, ask and contemplate.
    Even in the way we read the Holy Scriptures we see that we do not use the tools of analysis that are used to examine literary pieces. We read the same Scripture to adults, children, intelligent and less intelligent people the same. The living Word of God first enters the heart of a person and helps their faith grow, and then sets on the intellect to give understanding and teach.
    That does not mean we negate the benefits of education. On the contrary, we are urged to study the Scriptures and not be lazy but use and further all the talents God has entrusted us with, to multiply them and benefit ourselves and others for His glory. Wisdom in the divine things, and the understanding of life though is not gained by being an expert in many fields but by carefully guarding the heart and increasing the spiritual life.
    So if we are having difficulty persuading people of the existence of angels and demons, that is ok. Most of us do not understand all there is to it, but we can always grow. People in my experience are attracted to true worship and theology in their hearts when they find it. Attending services can speak very loudly sometimes, whilst trying to evangelize by trying to describe those things is much more difficult. Understanding and faith come to those that earnestly seek it. I find a certain passage very consoling and strengthening: Mark 9:24 â??Lord, I believe; help my unbelief!â??
    I have seen spiritual fathers behave in different ways when an enquirer approaches them. An example that comes to mind is when a very nice and very evangelical protestant friend approached one of our good priests and started asking questions in a manner that was rather trying to attack Orthodoxy instead of understanding it. The priest showed little patience in informing him that his belief system is just a plain corruption of the Truth though he did try to explain briefly the meaning of Tradition. I initially was surprised by the harshness. I have seen the same priest though getting into wonderful long discussions with other enquirers and saw that it does matter for a persons heart to be clean of pride when seeking understanding.
    If we are thinking we can approach our Holy Orthodox Faith and understand it with our limited means and even criticize it, then pride will certainly lead us astray. If we eagerly truly seek understanding with humility and trust we can probably ask, read and discuss all we want.
    Now as far as evangelizing though we still need to do work. Surely it is strange to keep Orthodoxy out of the public sight, letting others know of our presence is probably a good thing. Iâ??m thinking that making Orthodox books more widely available, participating in other political, religious or whatever other forums where we actually talk about our Faith (as it hopefully informs our views) and having commentaries by Orthodox people published are all good tools. Inviting friends to celebrate a nameday or Slava and explaining what that is, explaining our Icons at home and the office desk, fasting and crossing ourselves are all personal witness tools that sometimes fall on good soil. I also like the existence of the radio program receive.org playing in secular radio stations, as it makes our Faith part of our daily life, just like music is for many of us. Welcoming committees in Churches, a bulletin distributed to anyone who signs up whether they are a member or not and information on good websources and listings in search engines all seem good ideas.
    I do not mean to undermine Michaelâ??s point, that visiting the sick, suffering, tending to the needs of those around us are a powerful way of showing our Christianity. We do need though to also show where we get the direction, inspiration and strength from.

  11. Dia writes: “Nowadays people just do not really believe in the supernatural.”

    I think it’s more than that. It’s that for most people the supernatural is meaningless, except as a form of entertainment at the movies. They simply do not relate to life that way. Telling someone about a miracle is like giving him a handful of horseshoe nails — “what am I supposed to do with this?” — would be the response.

    Dia: “We also believe in miracles big and smaller and have a pretty significant mystical component intertwined in our Faith and everyday life practices.”

    See, here’s where I part ways with the Orthodox. I don’t have any problem with the idea of mystery, or with the idea that spiritual and moral truths can be communicated through miracles and doctrines. But I don’t necessarily “believe” in them. For example, I find the concept of the Trinity to be very inspiring and meaningful, as well as mysterious. But I’m happy to leave it at that. I would have a hard time saying that I “believe” in the Trinity. “Belief” to me is something that is the result of a rational process of evaluating evidence. So for me it is simply incompatible to say that I “believe” in something that is fundamentally mysterious and inexplicable. I think there is an important difference between faith and belief.

    For me, many of the Christian doctrines are attempts to comprehend something that is incomprehensible. To require “belief” in them kills something. It’s like the difference between seeing a beautiful butterfly in the wild, vs. killing it and pinning it to a board. In the first case you experience the beauty and mystery of the creature. In the second case you have a dead bug in a collection.

  12. # So Jim if you don’t believe Christian doctrine to be “believable” truths on their merit, do you then find them to be truths through your own understanding?

    Hopefully to clarify for understanding, do you only considered them believable truths through your own personal rational acceptance of them?

    And in a similar theme is the Eucharist only valid because you have rationalized its understanding within your own thought? It’s valid only because you accept its validity?

  13. Jim,

    The hopeful thing is that we do not have horseshoes but we do have an eternal soul. So even if most people are not ready at any given time to “understand” or logically accept the significance of miracles or divine presence and spiritual powers, many people wonder about eternity, afterlife spirits and their soul from time to time. We do that because we somehow “know” or feel there’s something to understand or find. That is why cults and religions develop all over the place throughout the ages. This is why yoga, wicca and paganism are back in fashion. Many people feel there is “something” there and are trying to get in touch with it willing to try whatever.

    “Belief” to me is something that is the result of a rational process of evaluating evidence.

    How unfortunate it is that we have to communicate in English!
    Well, no! “Belief” in matters of Faith is something you hold true without necessarily “knowing” it to be true because of scientific proof or other evidence.

    “For me, many of the Christian doctrines are attempts to comprehend something that is incomprehensible.”

    That is also not so. Orthodoxy is the one that sais for the Dogmas that (in my own words): “we know this is so because of God’s revelations. We do not understand/comprehend it as human beings with our limited powers, so we cannot explain it in human-logic terms. However God said so (or showed so) and this is enough for us. We hold it true and indisputable”

    The belief in the Trinity as an example is one of the Dogmas of the Orthodox Church. We do not comprehend the union and individuality but proclaim it. We have a lot of reverence for the Holy Trinity as well as a lot of humility because of the fact that we are not the ones that came up with the idea.
    This prayer, offered by the priest I believe before he asks for the transubstantiation of the Holy Gifts during Pentecost give a god although not complete description of who God is:

    “O most pure, undefiled, unoriginate, invisible, incomprehensible, inscrutable, immutable, invincible, immeasurable, gentle Lord, Who alone dost possess immortality, Who dwellest in light unapproachable…”

    Orthodoxy has many words to describe what God is not, as cannot really describe wholly what He is. So here is the “apophatic” approach of proclaiming that He is not visible, not comprehensible, not measurable. We do know though that He is gentle, philanthropic, Love (and that Christ is the Truth)

    I am certainly not the one to give more detail on this, but I hope I’ve made the point that NO! Orthodoxy does not try to comprehend the incomprehensible, but calls it “mystery” and believes in it because His Church cannot do anything but trust her groom.

  14. Jerry writes: “So Jim if you don’t believe Christian doctrine to be ‘believable’ truths on their merit, do you then find them to be truths through your own understanding?”

    I’m not sure what you mean by “on their own merit” here, unless you mean that they are intrinsically meaningful and inspiring. In that sense I would say that they are true, in the sense that they express moral and spiritual truths. But it does not follow from that that they are literally true.

    Let me give you an example. Atomic theory explains many phenomena. It is a very powerful theory. But the way we typically understand the theory, and the way it is usually presented, is that there are these little balls rotating around each other, and other balls that are glued to each other. More complex compounds are held together by these little sticks representing forces.

    Now I know that matter isn’t made up of little balls and sticks. But it’s the only way I can conceive of it. Looked at literally, scientists say that particles exist in two different places at once, that there are eleven different dimensions, and so on. But none of that means anything to me. So I go with the balls and sticks.

    So is the “ball and stick” version of atomic theory true in the strongest sense of the word? Of course not. It’s obviously false. But is it true in the sense that it helps us to understand something about the universe that otherwise would be impossible to grasp, even partially? In that sense it certainly is true.

    Here’s a theological example. We talk about the “persons” of the Trinity. We use this and other anthropological concepts in talking about God, because this is the only way we can conceive of God. It doesn’t mean that our concepts have some kind of isomorphic relationship to the deity, or that the concepts are “true” in a factual sense. In other words, I see a “mystery” as not only something that cannot be grasped rationally, but also something that by its very nature is quite beyond any concept.

    Jerry: “And in a similar theme is the Eucharist only valid because you have rationalized its understanding within your own thought? It’s valid only because you accept its validity?”

    Here I am not sure what you mean by “valid.”

Comments are closed.