Slippery-slope concerns are valid over stem-cell research John Leo July 31, 2006

Just when you think the debate over embryonic stem cells can’t get any more degraded, an outfit called the Campaign to Defend the Constitution comes along and proves you wrong. The group took out two vitriolic full-page ads in The New York Times (at $200,000 a pop) lashing out at religious conservatives as extremists and ideologues for opposing federal funding of embryonic stem-cell research (ESCR).

This was too much for my friend and former colleague Peter Steinfels, who, although religious and morally nuanced, is allowed to write a weekly “Beliefs” column for The New York Times. He wondered whether the labels “extremist” and “ideologue” were supposed to cover all religious people who have moral qualms about killing embryos. He wrote: What about the Catholic bishops, who opposed the Iraq war, or “the respected bioethicists who advised the president on his position five years ago”? Are they all unprincipled people imposing their will on the American public?

Steinfels went to the trouble of interviewing one Jessica Smith, the director of the Campaign to Defend the Constitution, who “seemed uncertain” about whether religious folk who disagree with her are all extremists. She must be new at the propaganda game because she foolishly told Steinfels that whether people like the Catholic bishops are extremists “depends on the topic.” Presumably this means that the bishops keep shuffling between extremism and non-extremism, the latter occurring when they agree with Smith. The latter would happen on the death penalty and soft treatment of illegal immigrants.

. . . more


1 thought on “Slippery-slope concerns are valid over stem-cell research”

  1. Today’s OT update included an article by Smith that embryos are not the only source of stem cells.

    Good reminder … stem cells come in other packages besides embryonic …

    Those of you who can encourage Philoptochos or local groups to support 100% cord blood saves at targeted local hospitals (link up with Red Cross or another place with adequate storage) would be helping do a great thing.

    In Christ,


Comments are closed.